The axes
Two strategies compose when they split different dimensions. TP and Ulysses
both touch heads but compose serially — TP splits the projection weights, then
Ulysses splits the activations of the TP-local heads. Ring and Ulysses compose
because ring splits rows while Ulysses splits heads. Ring has no composition
with a K/V-all-gather style of attention parallelism: both answer the same
question (how a rank’s query rows see remote K/V), so they are alternatives for
one slot, not complements.
What happens to the shapes
Fortp_size = T, ulysses_degree = U, ring_degree = R, one attention runs:
sp_degree=2 defaults to kv_gather_degree=2 — its
measured-win zone — and higher degrees default to Ulysses.
Ulysses groups are laid out on contiguous ranks and ring groups on strided
ranks, so with a node-major rank mapping, Ulysses traffic stays on intra-node
NVLink (all-to-all needs full-bisection bandwidth) while ring hops cross the
slower interconnect where neighbor-only transfers overlap with compute. A
mis-mapped layout stays numerically correct and silently loses the performance
— worth checking when a sharded run is unexpectedly slow.
Constraints
num_attention_heads % tp_size == 0— TP splits heads at the projections.(num_attention_heads / tp_size) % ulysses_degree == 0— Ulysses splits the TP-local heads.H % U == 0alone is not sufficient: 56 heads pass withtp=2, ulysses=4(28 % 4) and fail withtp=4, ulysses=4(14 % 4).- Ring adds no head constraint (it splits rows), but the sequence — including
any model-specific packing alignment — must divide by
ulysses × ring, since ring adds an outer row split on top of Ulysses’s inner one. - Ring requires an attention backend that declares
supports_ring_rotation()— the per-hop merge needs the kernel’s softmax LSE.faandsage_attndeclare it; the launcher auto-selectsfawhen unset. USPAttention’s masked/tail-padded text path and its replicated-prefix, -suffix, and -kv-prefix paths all support ring: the sharded K/V rotates through the ring while the tail-pad or replicated portion is attended locally once and combined into the ring result with the same online-softmax merge. This covers the joint text+image attention most models use (flux, flux_2, qwen_image, zimage, glm_image, ernie_image, and others).- What still raises
NotImplementedErrorunder ring:USPAttention’s generic varlen path (multiple packed segments per row, as used by HunyuanVideo — no ring-aware rotation for it yet), and the legacy stacked-QKVUlyssesAttentionlayer, now down to one user (Wan’s VSA sparse-attention variant) that has no softmax LSE to merge and can’t gain ring support without a different kernel. - The launcher validates
num_gpusagainst the product of the degrees and fails fast on any mismatch.
The Ulysses transport
The all-to-alls normally run over NCCL. On exactly 2 GPUs with peer-to-peer access, a CUDA-IPC transport replaces them by default: each rank writes its half directly into the peer’s mapped staging buffer, with GPU-side sequence counters instead of a NCCL rendezvous. An all-to-all is a permutation, never a reduction, so the transport cannot change results — outputs are bitwise identical to the NCCL path.
Independently of the transport, the default path already packs the three
Q/K/V input exchanges into one destination-major collective. A handful of
models (e.g. LTX-2) instead opt into
enable_packed_qkv_input_a2a, which
pipelines three separate exchanges over a dedicated stream rather than
merging them into one payload — a different trade-off, not a strict
upgrade over the default.
Which axes tolerate crossing nodes
Each axis has a fixed communication pattern, and the pattern — volume per step, how often it fires, and whether it can hide behind compute — decides whether the axis survives the drop from NVLink to the inter-node fabric. Ordered from most to least cross-node friendly:
Two caveats keep this a map rather than a promise. Cross-node launch
(
--nnodes/--node-rank/--dist-init-addr) is merged, and per-model ring
support is broad now (see the constraints above) — but those two facts
together still don’t add up to “any model, any node count.” The only
configuration actually run end-to-end across nodes is the H3 recipe; other
models’ ring support is same-node-validated so far, which means crossing
nodes with them is untested, not disallowed. And the data-parallel row
describes the design: the current
implementation binds each replica’s ingress on the local host, so replicas
spanning hosts additionally need per-replica host addressing before --dp-size
can place one replica per node.
Choosing a configuration
Measured guidance rather than rules — the right combination depends on the model’s communication profile and the hardware topology, and legal does not mean profitable:- Multi-branch (true-CFG) models: CFG parallelism first. Branches run the whole DiT independently and combine once per step, avoiding per-layer communication entirely.
- Single-branch image models on 2 GPUs: Ulysses and TP trade places by model. Communication-heavy DiTs measured faster with Ulysses; smaller DiTs with TP. Measure both; do not copy a winner across models.
- Long video / packed sequences: Ulysses up to the head-divisibility limit, then ring for the remaining factor — sequence length scales past the head count where Ulysses alone cannot.
- When Ulysses’s head divisibility blocks the degree you need (
H/Tnot divisible by the targetU): the row-splitting slot sidesteps it — ring today, or--kv-gather-degree(it splits rows, so it adds no head constraint either). - TP beyond 2 ranks rarely improves image-DiT latency: the per-block all-reduce grows with rank count faster than the GEMM savings.
Data parallelism
--dp-size N runs N full engine replicas on num_gpus / N GPUs each, every
replica with its own ingress. Generation requests round-robin across replicas,
realtime sessions stick to the replica holding their state, and control
operations (weights, LoRA, memory occupation, shutdown) apply to every replica;
replicas exchange nothing on the request path. Monolithic serving only, and the
ingress currently binds on the local host — one replica per node needs
per-replica host addressing first.